
I realized yesterday that I've never explained how I came to the decision that I was going to adopt Henny. It wasn't something that I took lightly, not after things with Minnie didn't work out (although she now happily lives with my parents and their other dog, Sasha, so all's well that ends well, I guess). In fact, the reason I wanted to foster in the first place is that I thought it would be fun to have a dog around, but I absolutely did not want to make a commitment to owning one. I didn't go into fostering with any desire to adopt.
For the first week or so that I had Henny, I was really uncertain about her. She was so traumatized and shut off from the world that it seemed like living had no upside for her; I honestly wondered if a dog in her state wouldn't be better off being euthanized. And even though the cats didn't seem overly bothered by Henny's presence, I felt really guilty about disrupting our quiet little routine.
Luckily, Henny started to relax a little, especially once we started going for walks. She learned how to play and showed interest in toys for the first time. After a while, I started to think about keeping her, but not for the exact right reasons. She was cute, polite, and quiet. She was a good walker. And, most of all, I was extremely defensive where she was concerned; I didn't like the thought of her going off to somebody else's home, living with people who wouldn't understand how to treat her. They don't sound like bad reasons, but they also weren't good enough.
In early December, I watched the Nova program 'Dogs Decoded', and I was reminded what dogs are 'supposed' to be like. After that, a switch was flipped in me, and I knew that Henny and I weren't meant to be together. Maybe, I thought, I'd get a dog someday, but it wasn't going to be Henny. She was too messed up from her past, and I didn't think she'd ever be able to connect with me the way a dog should. I cared a lot about her, but she couldn't return that feeling. Decision made.
But then... Christmastime rolled around. I took her to my parents on Christmas Eve, where we were around a lot of extended family, and then we spent the night there. I had tried to get Henny out to socialize here and there, but she'd never had anything as intense as a day with a house full of people. Surprisingly, she seemed to react well to the energy; she was cautious but interested, not closed off and staring at a wall, as she had been when I first met her. And more importantly, it was like something clicked in her brain. In this sea of people she didn't recognize, she knew me. After Christmas, she started to trust me a lot more, and people began to comment on the way she looked at me with devotion.
Then I went to LA for two weeks, and I found myself constantly wishing Henny were around. Public spaces and shops, etc, are much more dog-friendly there, and I kept thinking about how much fun it would be if I had Henny with me. That was when I knew I wanted to adopt her -- for real. It didn't matter that she wasn't a 'normal' dog, because she made my days happier just being who she was. And in the weeks since her adoption, she's continued to open up and trust me more, something that I think will continue.
I have a couple of friends who occasionally talk about adopting a dog, and this is my biggest piece of advice: find a rescue operation that will let you foster first. It's kind of insane to think that you can spend ten minutes with a dog and then sign a piece of paper that bonds you together for the rest of the dog's life -- I learned that the hard way, with Minnie. It would be like getting married after the first date. Especially if you've never had a dog before, it's hard to understand that they vary in personality -- and (this is so important) the dog you see on adoption day will almost certainly not be the dog you wind up with in a week or two. Quiet, shy dogs can become destructive terrors once they get comfortable in your home. Not always, but sometimes.
When I adopted Minnie, I was sure that I wanted a dog, and she seemed sweet and gentle. She is sweet, but she's actually rather neurotic, in a way that I can't deal with. My parents love her, but she stressed me out. Every dog isn't a good match for every person. I knew fairly quickly after I adopted her that it wasn't right, but what was done was done. I'm really happy -- and Minnie is very lucky -- that my parents chose to adopt her from me.
When I started fostering Henny, I was sure that I did not want a dog, and she seemed like a total mess. She's still messed up, but the things about her that probably wouldn't work for somebody else are what make her the perfect dog for me. There's just no way I could have known that if I'd been choosing a dog to permanently adopt instead of temporarily foster.
And that's how we wound up together.